search
top

Quick Hits: Hillsborough County, Everyday Antiracism and Stephen Krashen Worship

Some old, some new, some blogs, some traditional media. All worthwhile, ‘cuz we’ve got Florida, race and Reading First.

jennifer faliero, hillsborough county school board

The travel debate in Hillsborough County, Florida [St. Pete Times].

The travel expenses are in - board member Susan Valdes spent a lot, no doubt. But $50k over 4 years isn’t all that much if the travel/conferences were worthwhile. Her unfriendlier colleagues on the Board point to the gaudy number and never once address what she actually did with the funds.

There’s no evidence of impropriety, just frequent professional development. The horror!

And cue the gall from Jennifer Faliero:

Board Chairwoman Jennifer Faliero, who requested the four-year analysis of travel by elected officials, agreed. She led the call for a temporary halt on out-of-county travel at the last meeting.

She doesn’t think travel should continue during a time of budget cuts, but acknowledged that other board members don’t agree. She is pushing for oversight and budgeting that would equalize travel among officials.

“We didn’t have a policy, so you leave yourself open to all kinds of abuses,” said Faliero, whose own expenses totaled $13,000. “Even though you hope people will use common sense, that hasn’t happened here.”

Golly gee, it’s almost as if Ms. Faliero doesn’t want Ms. Valdes to win re-election!

Of course, everyone will remember that Ms. Faliero didn’t see it fit to live in the district she was actually representing [she moved back after public pressure]. If anyone is to criticize a board member about using common sense, it isn’t Faliero.

In the tradition of Ann Landers, I’ll issue a Confidential to Jennifer Faliero:

Grow up, you partisan hack. Or at least be politically savvy enough to conceal your motives more effectively.

http://www.matthewktabor.com/images/victorian_line.gif

mica pollock, everyday antiracism

Getting Real About Race in School [Eduwonkette].

This is old news, but it’s worth revisiting. Eduwonkette featured as a guest blogger Harvard’s Mica Pollack, author of Everyday Antiracism: Getting Real about Race in School.

And to think, I’ve only been committed to anti-racism on Tuesdays, Thursdays and every other Saturday!

Pollock’s guest post is another in a series of Eduwonkette’s reminders that you [or me, or anyone, I guess] should know Pollock’s name. May 21st’s summer reading list suggestion and May 30th’s “Cool People You Should Know” nod apparently weren’t enough. Perhaps a hidden tenet of “Everyday Antiracism” is that we need to be reminded of it every day.

But Pollock’s debate is what warrants attention here. After repeating the 4 bullet points that explain the core of “Everyday Antiracism” - I’d bother linking to them if they weren’t repeated in half of Pollock’s posts - some commenters engaged Pollock in rigorous, sensible debate.

And you know how it goes. When the going gets tough, some just get going. Not everyone thought Pollock’s Kool-Aid tasted sweet, so she huffed, puffed, took her ball and went home.

I came late to the party [and the commenters raised all the issues I wanted to address, so I was content with just reading], but I’ll reprint my comment here:

“If you have thoughts on how guest blogging could be organized differently, let me know - but I don’t see any other way around this.” [eduwonkette]

It’s a very, very simple rule that can apply to guest bloggers - don’t engage in a discussion you can’t finish, or at least stick with for a little while.

I’m not particularly interested in the excuses for why Pollock or anyone else can’t be expected to carry on a discussion. And really - Pollock is committed to reforming humanity’s attitudes on race, but can’t be bothered to address substantive points made by interested, knowledgeable commenters?

I’ll draw on Senator B. H. Obama’s recent rhetoric to sum this up:

“Any fool can write a blog post… it’s the courage to engage in discussion that makes you a blogger.”

Pollock abandoned her blog-baby the moment it started teething - end of story.

I suppose we’ll see further discussion at schoolracetalk.org.

http://www.matthewktabor.com/images/victorian_line.gif

rotten apple

Silence [right here on the Aughts].

Silly me, I decided to judge Stephen Krashen’s latest Reading First USAToday Crap-Ed piece on its merits. I thought that Reid Lyon’s argument was more compelling.

Gary Stager took me to task. His pith:

“Dr. Krashen is an internationally respected expert in how children develop language. Reid Lyon is not.”

Very true. In related news, Gary Stager sports a mustache while I prefer a full beard.

Anyone can put out a stinker regardless of what they’ve done in the past. I happen to think that Krashen is full of stinkers, but that’s beside the point. His editorial, again, was not compelling - and when you write as many letters to the editor and op-eds as Krashen does, it happens. I replied:

Gary,

I have and will continue to put more stock in the merits of one’s argument than in one’s CV.

Oddly enough, you cited Krashen’s reputation as evidence of his superiority on this issue just a day or two before you busted on David Warlick for being hired, largely based on prior work and reputation, to deliver keynotes when you intimate that he has little to offer. [I found it refreshing that David admitted that it was getting tougher to develop proper keynote topics, but I digress.] If you’ve got a rubric that determines when reputation is an asset, a la Krashen, and when it is to be discarded, a la Warlick, I’d love to see it.

Silence, silence, silence.

No Responses to “Quick Hits: Hillsborough County, Everyday Antiracism and Stephen Krashen Worship”

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. BREAKING: Hillsborough Election Results Are In, Valdes Wins, Kurdell Doesn’t at Education for the Aughts - American School Issues and Analysis - [...] Valdes over Schmidt. Good, she’s alright. I guess this means Faliero’s childish attacks didn’t work. Sorry, [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

top